Researchers at the National Institutes of Health have found evidence
that a unique type of immune cell contributes to multiple sclerosis
(MS). Their discovery helps define the effects of one of the newest
drugs under investigation for treating MS — daclizumab — and could lead
to a new class of drugs for treating MS and other autoimmune disorders.
In these disorders, the immune system turns against the body's own
tissues. Ongoing clinical trials have shown that daclizumab appears to
help quiet the autoimmune response in MS patients, but its precise
effects on the legions of cells that make up the immune system are not
fully understood.
The new study, published in Science Translational Medicine, shows
that one effect of daclizumab is to thin the ranks of lymphoid tissue
inducer (LTi) cells. These cells are known to promote the development
of lymph nodes and related tissues during fetal life, but their role
during adulthood has been unclear. The new study marks the first time
that LTi cells have been implicated in any human autoimmune disorder.
"While further study is required to confirm the role of LTi cells in
autoimmunity, our results point to the cells as a promising target for
the development of new drugs to treat autoimmune disorders," said
Bibiana Bielekova, M.D., an investigator at NIH's National Institute of
Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS).
Dr. Bielekova and her team found that among MS patients participating
in clinical trials of daclizumab, the number of LTi cells was elevated
in patients not receiving daclizumab compared to those on the drug.
Patients receiving daclizumab also had reduced signs of inflammation in
the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) that surrounds the brain. And the
researchers found that daclizumab appears to steer the body away from
producing LTi cells, in favor of another cell type that counteracts
autoimmunity.
In MS, the immune system attacks myelin, a material that insulates
nerve fibers running throughout the brain and spinal cord. This
typically leads to vision loss, and other sensory changes such as
numbness and tingling, weakness, and fatigue. The disorder affects
approximately 400,000 people in the United States. In about 85 percent
of patients, MS starts as a relapsing-remitting form, in which symptoms
come and go. Many patients eventually develop secondary progressive MS,
in which symptom flare-ups are followed by worsening disability. Many
medications are available to decrease the number of flare-ups, but no
medication is effective at slowing the course of progressive MS.
The newer, sophisticated drugs for relapsing-remitting MS target key
cells and molecules responsible for triggering and maintaining
autoimmunity. Cytotoxic T cells, the immune system's specialized mobile
infantry, are known to lead the attack. Antibodies, the immune system's
guided missiles, appear to help reinforce it.
Daclizumab is a lab-engineered antibody, or monoclonal antibody, that
alters signaling by interleukin-2 (IL-2), a key factor that mobilizes T
cells. In a large clinical trial (
NCT00109161), it has shown promise as an add-on therapy for patients taking the approved MS drug interferon-beta. Another ongoing trial (
NCT00390221) is investigating whether or not daclizumab is effective as a stand-alone therapy for reducing relapses in MS.
The drug was designed to suppress T cell responses to IL-2, and it does so — but Dr. Bielekova had found previously that
this suppression is indirect
and depends on other immune cells. For example, one effect of
daclizumab is to stimulate the non-specialized counterparts of T cells,
called natural killer cells. These cells in turn suppress T cell
activity.
In their new study, Dr. Bielekova and her team discovered that
daclizumab's stimulatory effect on natural killer cells is paired with
an inhibitory effect on LTi cells. They found evidence that the drug,
via its effects on IL-2 signaling, acts on a type of stem cell. The
drug appears to decrease the likelihood that this stem cell will develop
into LTi cells, and sway it toward becoming natural killer cells.
"This helps explain why natural killer cells are activated and their
numbers are expanded by daclizumab therapy," Dr. Bielekova said.
Meanwhile, she said, the drop in LTi cells was "intriguing" in itself,
given the cells' role in lymph node development.
Lymph nodes — found conspicuously in the armpits, neck and groin —
are patches of tissue where T cells and antibody-producing B cells set
up camp. Inside the nodes, T cells and B cells are found in clusters
called lymphoid follicles, where they wait for a signal that the body is
under siege from infection. In autoimmune disorders, abnormal lymphoid
follicles can develop and contribute to the autoimmune response.
Secondary progressive MS, in particular, is associated with abnormal
lymphoid follicles in the connective tissues (or meninges) surrounding
the brain. These are believed to contribute to chronic brain
inflammation in MS, eventually leading to shrinkage of the brain.
Dr. Bielekova and her team reasoned that daclizumab, by suppressing
LTi cells, should reduce the growth of lymphoid follicles. Since it is
not possible to visualize these follicles in the live brain, the
researchers measured the effects of daclizumab on markers of
inflammation in the CSF. They found that CXCL13, a protein linked to
lymphoid growth, and the IgG index, a measure of antibody production,
decreased by an average of 50.4 percent and 13.5 percent, respectively,
in trial participants who took the drug for six and half months.
"To our knowledge, no other MS therapy reduces IgG index," Dr. Bielekova said.
She cautioned that these data provide only an indirect link between
LTi cells and brain inflammation in MS. If further research confirms
that the cells play an important role in MS or other autoimmune
disorders, "pursuing the development of new drugs to selectively inhibit
LTi cells could be a useful therapeutic strategy," she said.
This study was funded by the NIH-NINDS intramural research program.
The lead authors were Justin Perry and Sungpil Han. Mr. Perry was a
fellow in NIH's Postbaccalaureate Intramural Research Training Award
program, and is currently a Ph.D. student in the neuroscience program at
Washington University in St. Louis. Mr. Han is an M.D.-Ph.D. student
at Pusan National University in South Korea, and is supported in part by
a fellowship from the Korea Research Foundation to study at NIH.
Patient data were derived from a small completed trial (
NCT00071838)
which showed that daclizumab may reduce lesions in relapsing-remitting
MS, and from an ongoing trial to investigate the drug's mode of action (
NCT01143441).
NINDS (
http://www.ninds.nih.gov)
is the nation’s leading funder of research on the brain and nervous
system. The NINDS mission is to reduce the burden of neurological
disease – a burden borne by every age group, by every segment of
society, by people all over the world.